I just sold a house to a past client that reminded me of something that happened almost 20 years ago.
The house this client bought was a good solid house. The current owner built the house and took good care of it. It really just needs some updating, fresh paint and new flooring. The seller sold the house for less than they could have gotten had they done these improvements. They passed on the savings they had to the buyer who was happy to get a good deal on a good house and use the savings to update to his own taste. This really worked out well for both of them.
There was a little gap between what the seller wanted and what the buyer wanted to pay. Not a huge gap. I told the buyer that I knew he would end up renovating any house he bought. He enjoys working on houses and has improved every house he has owned. I told him the story of two houses right across the street from each other that were essentially the same house.
Back in the early 2000s, there were two houses for sale on the same street. Both were split levels of similar size and floor plan. One was pretty nice and was $150k…..which would be like $250k today. The house across the street was $118k and needed everything.
I bought the $118k house because that was all I could afford at the time, but I secretly wished I could have bought the one across the street for $150k because I liked the yard better.
I bought my house for $118k and over the course of several years, ripped out all the old, tired, worn out finishes and replaced them with new materials.
The house across the street that sold for $150k closed shortly after I closed my house. I met the new owners. Great people. Over the course of the next couple years, I saw them rip out and haul off everything that made that house worth $32k more than my house. They ripped up perfectly good carpet because they wanted hardwood. Understandable. They didn’t like the looks of the kitchen counter top even though it was in excellent shape. This continued for quite a while.
One day I was talking to the husband and I finally said what had been on my mind for quite some time. I said “You should have bought my house instead. You have thrown away everything that made your house worth $32k more than my house.” He paused for a second and had a deep thought look on his face. Then he said he had never thought of it that way. He saw materials he didn’t like and was excited about fixing up his house. I saw $32k going in a dumpster.
He probably walked in to my house when both were for sale and was turned off by everything being worn out. That is understandable too. But if you know you are going to renovate a house to your taste, it is better to start with one where you are paying less and ripping out worn out materials.
I can’t wait to see what this buyer does with his new house. And I would have never guessed something I learned that long ago would still be benefiting my clients today!